Well, what the Stoics are getting at with this notion of a concept of a divine being part of our very intuitive resources—that belief in such a being is sort of built in—what they are getting at is that a rational being, recognizing the orderliness and lawfulness of the cosmos, must match that up, without further deliberation, with the notion of some rational agency behind it.
Stoicism — Bridging Faith and Philosophy Now, again, these debts and debates were inevitable and productive. What have I got wrong or missed out? Anyway, back to this idea of giving up your will and serving the Logos.
This is a major difference, and one of the reasons I moved beyond Stoicism to Christianity, because I believe in grace — in moments when God lifts us up and puts us back on our feet. Perhaps the acknowledgement simply became more grudging or reluctant. Once there, the visiting scholar sees not merely the statues and classical architecture.
To Christ, they would be just as beautiful as any other child of God. Apocalyptic thought is not exactly compatable with the cynic philosophy, or the stoic philosophies either. The idea of askesis is still strong in Orthodox Christianity, which in general seems to me much closer to Greek philosophy, while modern Evangelicalism seems to have thrown that entire tradition out in favour of loud and slightly soupy declarations of love for Jesus.
Reconciling Competing Views Between Stoicism and Christianity The Jews, the Christians, and the Jewish Christians deny the materiality of God as envisaged by Stoic philosophy; so, here we have a bind of sorts—a Stoic philosophical authority for a rational plan, something that is active and present in the world, something that makes the Comparing christianity and stoicism essay conform to the scheme, but, at the same time, not something revealed directly to human intelligence.
Perhaps it is this flexibility that is one of the reasons it keeps appearing. Now, in this account, the defining feature of the creative power of the universe is its inexhaustibility and its rationality. To be a Hellenized Jew at the time of the life of Jesus Christ is, among other considerations, to be a scholar—someone who has perhaps gone to Athens, but who has in any case regarded the ideas taught in Athens as the apex of philosophical wisdom.
Philo of Alexandria was born in 20 B. There are quotes from the early Stoics which seem to support the claims the writers make.
But there is always something wrong with it according to these writers, something which, they maintain, caused it to dissipate though it was at one time the preferred philosophy and even religion of the thoughtful Roman upper and mid-to-upper classes. Philo of Alexandria He has studied philosophy, studied Aristotle and Plato, and, of course, is a faithful student of the Old Testament.
Consult the Ten Commandments; these come directly from God. As for me, I was never a Christian, but found a form of practical spirituality in ancient philosophy.
Or, more likely, both Early Christianity and late Cynicism were influenced by earlier Cynicism. Foundation of the Christian Faith St. There certainly seem to be a few parallels between Galilean Christianity whether Jesus himself or Q and the Cynics.
The Christian universe is, therefore, in some ways a much weirder, more polytheistic, and more dangerous place, teeming with evil spirits trying to destroy us.
They do these foolish things, time and again, and are swept along, eagerly defeating Comparing christianity and stoicism essay they really wish for.
The relationship with God is more emotional, more sensual, more dare I say it erotic than in Greek philosophy although there is an argument that this erotic aspect of worship is in Plato too.
They all seem to have certain claims in common, however. But then I suppose Socrates had a daemon too, and the Stoics did believe in pursuing eudaimonia having a kindly daemon within as opposed to kakadaimonia having an evil daemon within …so maybe there are more spirits in Greek philosophy than we realize!
I think this is partly why Christianity is much better at community than Stoicism — because communities need to be grounded in love, not rationality. We see Stoicism sometimes described as the noblest of the moral codes pagan antiquity managed to formulate.
Hellenistic Jews—Diaspora Jews who had adopted the language and culture of the hellenistic world. In this they can be compared to the evolving monotheism of Judaism, particularly that of Moses around two centuries earlier.
The cosmic creation is not undertaken for no reason at all. A Revolutionary Biography Click to expand This is easier to follow for verbal insults than physical ones, but even for physical ones it is foolish to be critical of the person who hurt you because of a fault they have that is likely to be common to everyone.
Sometimes, the comparisons that were made seem to be in earnest, and even thoughtful. Stoicism offers the obvious proofs for this—consider only the lawfulness of the cosmos itself. Was Jesus himself influenced heavily by Helenistic philosophy? They call for pious respect for the God of all, for the recognition that reality is a created reality, that it is an ordered affair that represents the perfected nature of whatever creative energy brought it about.
Well, those are some initial thoughts. Paul addresses his letters to people in the vast Roman world as he travels from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.
So there is much intellectual energy devoted to having the philosophical light brought to bear on the authority of faith. Love, by contrast, resists hierarchies.Jul 21, · I'd like to have a discussion on the similarities between Christianity and Stoicism as was found in the first century, and similarities with cynicism.
In Matters of Faith: Christianity vs. Stoicism Kevin Miller Course: HONR Instructor: Dr. Jim Walter Essay Type: Research Paper Introduction Over the course of human history every society, even the most culturally isolated of.
Tomorrow is the big event on Stoicism for Everyday Life in London, at which Mark Vernon and I will be discussing the relationship between Stoicism and Christianity. Mark has an interesting story to tell – he was a priest, who then left Christianity and found an alternative in Greek philosophy.
Free Essay: Introduction Over the course of human history every society, even the most culturally isolated of civilizations, has developed some form of. Comparing Stoicism and Christianity Anyone who does some reading about Stoicism has encountered books in which it is compared, unfavorably, to Christianity.
These books seem to have been written, at the latest, in the 19th and early 20th centuries. Christianity and Stoicism Essay - Stoicism emerged in Hellenistic Greece as a new way of reasoning.
A way of fulfilling one’s spiritual duty. It quickly became one of the most important Post Classical Greek philosophies. For the purpose of my analysis, I have focused on the period BC to CE.Download