I enjoyed watching both films and the ways the directors were able to interpret and develop the characters. Use of sound also differs. Obviously one big difference is the time periods of each movie.
There are some very obvious differences including the intended audience, the setting, the place and the timing of the play. This is done very well with all the different types of music that are played and the way the camera moves quickly between showing each person and their reaction to the situation.
It includes modern cars, buildings, guns, drugs and many more things instead of swords or old houses, which show just how modern it is. This is why he begins the prologue with the television set, on the news, to give the viewer the instant impression that the film is set in the modern world, with media being an important factor.
A good example of the different techniques is at the beginning of the two films, the street fights. Then you hear a dramatic choir this most definitely suggest that their will be a lot of action and suspense. Here the camera starts off low, looking at the feet and legs of the person, then slowing raising up the the face as they introduce the character.
The images in the Luhrmann version are modern and media orientated. One picture is a police helicopter obviously it shows crime is happing and suggest the film defiantly has a mafia perspective.
Subsequently the Capulets arrive in their car with the design very much the same as the Montagues car but in a different colour. Straight after this happens we get introduced to Tybalt, the camera moves very slowly at this point showing him step on his cigar and emphasize the grinding of his heel on it, then the camera goes to his face and this is when his name appears.
This sets an unsettling affect. Then after the TV theirs a suction sound that sucks us into the film, this suggest that there will be a lot of suspense and thriller which shows modern day film action like drugs, sex and violence. Then we have a collection of images flashing and cascading across the screen flashing sneaking into the back of our minds giving us many suggestions about the film.
Why, I hear you ask? A lot of the characters including Romeo are sometimes seen smoking a cigarette. The Capulets do not like this at all and drive their car closer to the Montagues then get out and start arguing with the Montagues.
Then Baz Lurhmann lures us into the film buildings being burled on each side from this I can connote that the film will be full action, suspense and thriller and this is cohered by gun violence. It then shows the Montagues talking to each other but doing it in a very loud and menacing way and as Benvolio walks off screen the other two carry on causing trouble.
The message of an inspector calls Essay The techniques of filming are also different. And also will be the traditional re-enactment of William Shakespeare play.
It may even be the most well known play in the world! Then we zooming into the sun getting closer and closer to the full screen are covered in orange and red. Two specific characters that were portrayed very differently and are my favorite characters are Tybalt and Mercutio.
Between each time the camera switches it gets closer and closer to Benvolio and Tybalt until finally showing only their eyes and as all of this is going on cowboy music is being played again and it carries on throughout the shooting part.
In this version the Montagues also see the Capulets, which is seen from their point of view from afar showing an interesting use of the camera angle, and actually go to them looking for a fight. One critics view was: In both films the directors both use music to portray the film.
Zeffirelli prefers the softer approach to the film trying to draw you into it which almost immediately would make the younger generation bored but interesting for the older generations.
In keeping with the sets and effects, the costumes too are very different. Their families, the Montagues and Capulets, have been fierce enemies for generations. I can back my evidence up that the movie is in the medieval times due to the building styles and all their structures. This is a good technique to use to introduce an important character as the audience will know it must be someone important from the filming technique.
In Lurhmanns, there is spaghetti western style music to go with the gunplay and also the operatic music coming back in after the petrol station goes up in flames due to the gunfight at the beginning between the montagues and capulets.
On the other hand, the pictures presented to the audience in the Zeffirelli version are very old, swords instead of guns, horse instead of car etc.
Franco Zeffirelli went for a more traditional style, whereas Baz Luhrmann attempted to thrill his audience with a comedic modern twist, still keeping the original dialogue. This shows that the film will be traditional and fair and not a bulge of violent actions.
Reflections on the Novel Essay In the modern film the director has made the Montagues drive into a gas station with the camera on the floor and the car coming straight to it as if it is going to run it over but stops just before it can.
Most of the scenes in the film are portrayed in different ways although there are some similarities. In the older version by Zeffirelli the way it is shown to us is very different to the one I just described.
He made a movie which attracts all audiences and gets them interested and entertained just how Shakespeare did his plays in medieval era.Baz Luhrmann directed such films as Strictly Ballroom, Romeo and Juliet and the musical Moulin Rouge.
He has a very distinctive directing approach with particular techniques that define his style. He presents his films as if he were telling a story, which he invites you into. His stories are very 3/5(3). Home > Assignment Sample > Compare And Contrast The Two Film Versions Of Romeo And Juliet By Franco Zeffirelli And Baz Luhrmann.
We will write a custom essay sample on Any topic specifically for you For Only $/page. From all of this I connote that this film version produce by Franco Zeffirelli will be for a secluded audience, upper.
The two directors who have succeeded most at doing this are Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann, the two films I will be concentrating on. We Will Write A Custom Essay Sample On Any topic specifically In keeping with the sets and effects, the costumes too are very different.
On one hand, Zeffirellis film displays historically accurate. Get an answer for 'How do I compare Baz Luhrmann's and Franco Zeffirelli's versions of Romoe and Juliet?' and find homework help for other Romeo and. - Comparison of Romeo and Juliet Movies Franco Zeffirellis ‘Romeo & Juliet’ was the most popular film in the box office ineight years after he directed it on the stage in the West End.
Baz Luhrmann created his version thirty years later, in a modern style. Franco Zeffirelli And Baz Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet Essays: OverFranco Zeffirelli And Baz Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet Essays, Franco Zeffirelli And Baz Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet Term Papers, Franco Zeffirelli And Baz Luhrmann's Romeo And Juliet Research Paper, Book Reports.
ESSAYS, term and research.Download